PA Supreme Court to Reexamine Evidence in Medical Malpractice Case

March 28, 2018
Medical Malpractice Attorney Philadelphia PA

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has decided to reexamine one case’s acceptance of evidence in a recent medical malpractice lawsuit. The original case alleged that a doctor was negligent during the victim’s hysterectomy and that he accidentally severed her bowel during the surgery in 2013. At trial, the judge allowed the defense to explain to the jury the general risks associated with routine hysterectomies. The jury ultimately found that the doctor was not guilty of negligence.

A Superior Court later decided to order a new trial based on the trial judge’s acceptance of evidence surrounding the potential complications of hysterectomies. The Superior Court panel was concerned that such evidence may have influenced the jury in favor of the doctor. Such evidence, the panel argued, should not be relevant in medical negligence cases. The panel also agreed that information concerning the surgical risks of hysterectomies should only be admitted when questioning whether the patient had given informed consent to treatment or when establishing a standard of care.

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Set to Issue Ruling in Medical Malpractice Appeal

The Superior Court’s ruling, according to the defendants, conflicts with an earlier Supreme Court decision which allows information regarding known risks into evidence as it relates to the standard of care in specific medical procedures. Such evidence, the defense argues, can help jury members understand the potential for complications in the absence of negligent behavior. The Supreme Court has agreed to hear both arguments and make an official ruling on this matter.

Free Consultation with Experienced Medical Malpractice Lawyers in Philadelphia, PA

As experienced medical malpractice attorneys, the legal professionals at Baldwin Matzus, LLC have spent 20 years representing clients injured by doctors. We are prepared to handle complex medical cases, and we are ready to help you and your family understand your legal rights, argue your case to a jury, and pursue financial compensation for your injuries. The attorneys at Baldwin Matzus, LLC can be reached at (866) 858-2276.

The articles on this blog are for informative purposes only and are no substitute for legal advice or an attorney-client relationship. If you are seeking legal advice, please contact our law firm directly.


Baldwin Matzus Were
Incredibly Professional and Dedicated —
They Made Me Feel Like We Were a Team.


your team

Attorney Kila Baldwin
Jason Matzus
Joseph Froetschel
Laura Phillips
attorney image

Case Results

109M —
Electrocution Accident
80M —
Defective Product
57.1M —
Defective Product
more case results

* As to the case results mentioned above, attorney Kila Baldwin co-led the trial team at her prior firm that obtained these verdicts.

American Association for Justice
National Trial Lawyers - Top 100
Super Lawyers